Number of Captioneers
Number of Captions
Blue indicates the first prize winner.
Yellow indicates a good prize winner.
Robb: Luigi: Told ya Mario would look at anything I pointed to.
gnidaplat: Luigi was right, Lemmy throwing pies at Mario from a crate just isn't that funny in reality.
Lord Wilco: Lemmy: This isn't enough to cover the damage he did to my pies, pay up.
- Ludwig 222
- Lemmy: If you're lucky enough to see Mario get hit by ten pies now, you'll get $3 just for watching!
- Luigi: I bet Mario's having a good time…
- Blue Boo
- Lemmy: I can't believe you won the bet that three random pies would hit Mario while I stand on a box next to this big banner on sticks…
- Toddy Koopa
- Lemmy: Just 300 dollars a ticket, see the amazing getter hitter byer pieer iner header!
- Luigi: Stop it! Stop it! He's already dead!
- Lemmy: If you don't want tickets, get out of here, Luigi, and no you can't have the tickets for free if I haven't sold them yet.
- Luigi: Wow, just 300 dollars a ticket and I can watch the clouds go by.
- When Luigi buys the tickets, Lemmy has no idea that the cops are after him for the possession of counterfeit money!
- Lemmy: Try to give Mario brain damage, $5.
- Mark P
- Mario: Boy, this caption sure is an unlucky one…
- Luigi: OH MY GOODNESS! You've nearly knocked Mario unconscious!
- Mario: Next time, if I ever get splattered by pies again, I'll make sure I don't EVER go to the barber shop again!
- Lemmy's Land's new attraction: Splat The Mario.
- Lemmy: Bid your coins here on this Mario! Do I have 50 coins? No, 80? Do I hear 100 from Mario's brother?
- Luigi: Like I said, this isn't your golf course!
- Lemmy: Looks like I need to name my new island…
- Luigi was right, Lemmy throwing pies at Mario from a crate just isn't that funny in reality.
- Lord Wilco
- Lemmy: This isn't enough to cover the damage he did to my pies, pay up.
- Lil Miss Game & Watch
- Luigi: I want to play "Throw pies at Mario" too!
- Luigi: Save some for me!
- Lemmy's so stupid, he doesn't even know Luigi switched his ball for a box when he was watching Mario throw pies at himself.
- Lemmy: Don't waste my time with these bits of paper, give me coins now!
- Luigi: Mario, it's a pie EATING contest.
- Mario: Mmm, boysenberry!
- Lemmy: The idea was to knock ME off the box, but hey, I'm not complaining!
- Luigi: Told ya Mario would look at anything I pointed to.
- Luigi: Ha! I told you that Mario will hit himself with pies! Where's my 50 bucks?!
- Announcer: And the winner of the "Hit Mario with a Pie" contest is Luigi, defeating the champ, Lemmy.
- Mario: I-a deserved that-a. I've-a been a bad-a boy!
- Dark Magician
- Luigi: Well, I WOULD pay extra, but that's only if I get to lick the pie off his head.
- Mario: I know that contests are strange, but you EAT the pie, not THROW it!
- Did ya ever notice the clouds have eyes in Mario adventures?
- Lemmy: Now… how to get down?
- Lemmy: Now! Uh… now! Guys, did you forget the plan again? It's time to get the Marios!!!